We’re Losing our Minds

This is not a blog about all of us having watched too many of the presidential debates. Instead, it’s another in a series about higher education in America. The title comes from a new book of the same title, by authors Richard Keeling and Richard Hersch. I know Hersch a bit as he served as the president another fine liberal arts college, Hobart and William Smith, in the 90’s and then went on to lead Trinity (in Hartford, Conn) after that. Hersch and Keeling’s book, We’re Losing Our Minds, laments the limited learning happening on most college campuses these days. I got a good start on it this weekend and by the time I am through, you may hear from me again.

Here’s the premise. Beyond the implied assurance of employment (which one no longer can rely on), the idea of positive intellectual and personal growth lies at the heart of our hopes about, goals for, and confidence in higher education. College is meant to change people, to be a place where students develop greater understanding, can apply their new knowledge in the world, can articulate and defend a new perspective and show new personal, social and civic maturity. That’s why I love Oglethorpe’s motto so much: make a life, make a living and make a difference. Sitting passively through college is a waste of both individual and collective time and resources and unfortunately, according to the Richards, it is possible and increasingly common to do exactly that – to accumulate credit hours, meet basic academic requirements, and receive a degree without truly engaging in the process of real, substantive learning. I agree. And I also believe that the best preparation for one’s career or careers requires learning of this type, rather than a model that focuses simply on job training. I guess that why I am president of a liberal arts college where learning is what we do.

The other night I attended an event where the discussion wandered to the Occupy Wall Street movement. There were maybe 25 of us sitting around a table trying to solve the world’s problems. It’s been a couple of weeks and you probably have not noticed much of a change in the world order. Anyway, a half dozen of us worked in higher education. At one point in the conversation, one of those representing another institution remarked that the reaction of 99% of his student body to the movement was “go home and get a job”. He seemed quite comfortable with that sentiment. I, on the other hand, can‘t seem to shake the unease that I felt then and still feel now. It’s quite easy, I think, to take issue with lots of things about the movement and the people in the movement. On the other hand, the “go get a job” sentiment which I have heard from plenty of others is an awful simple way of looking at the real issues that have spawned the movement. I don’t think people who have been exposed to real , substantive learning would suggest that’s the be-all-and-end-all solution. I certainly know that I would be disappointed if a single Oglethorpe student approached the problem that way.

This entry was posted in Education, Policy and Politics and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to We’re Losing our Minds

  1. Gary Albright says:

    Ironic how when one has a job (or is safely ensconced in the relatively safe harbor of college) it can be so easy to slough off the concerns of others and tell those concerned and willing to put their derrieres on the line to “go home and get a job.” Of course, that’s one reason our public officials have been so late in taking the Occupy concerns seriously — as our pols comfortably feed at the trough. If there were jobs to be had perhaps their stance might be credible. Given that there are so few positions and so many vying for them, it’s unconscionable that anyone can be so glib about the dire employment scene facing so many.

  2. Totally agree with you, Gary … and it’s a very perceptive comment. Every time I think that 1 in 6 Americans (or maybe 1 in 12 if you believe the stats) is out of work, it sends a chill down my spine. The anxiety, desperation and stress of that has to be so intense… and so debilitating. I think the energy that was seen when people who were in this situation — and so largely invisible –could finally go out and stand up and be seen & heard, was simply not to be denied. The real surprise is that more of us aren’t out in the streets, demanding that the people who caused this sh**t storm face the consequences of what they have done.

  3. Paul B. Chen says:

    Wow. 99% opinion from a student body of an institution of higher education is hard to believe. University of Phoenix? Bob Jones? I am interested, however, in hearing more about why there is “limited learning happening on most college campuses.” What’s going on these days?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s