The City of Brookhaven: Yes or No?

I’ve written about this once before, but the campaign is heating up. “Yes” and “No” signs have started to appear on the front lawns of neighbors. So far, I don’t sense any ugliness in the campaign, not nearly as much heat as when the idea of speed bumps on our street became a political issue. On the issue of whether a new city of Brookhaven ought to be formed, I fall squarely into the “no” camp. The vote is unfortunately scheduled for July 31 when maybe one in ten voters will make it to the polls. Timing aside, I still have not found a compelling reason for such a dramatic change. For my university, which would all of a sudden find its home to be the City of Brookhaven instead of Atlanta, I don’t believe this is a good thing.

The two primary arguments for this new city are: 1). There will be local control of our new governmental entity. Frankly, I don’t even know what this means. Georgia has more counties (more local control?) than any state I know of. If more local control means our government will look anything like our state government , then I vote no. This is one of those slogans that feels good, but in reality, has little meaning. We elect representatives now, some of whom serve me well and some don’t. I can’t foresee this changing. In this case, the folks who dreamed up this idea never asked me or my institution what we thought of the plan to become a new city. Given that, why would I think I would be better represented under new leadership?

Argument number 2): Everyone’s taxes will go down. If you believe this, I have a bridge to sell you. I have never seen an efficient governmental entity and I don’t care if Republicans or Democrats are running the thing. But governments are necessary and they serve an important role in our lives and the life of our country. If Brookhaven becomes a new city, though, we will still have to support DeKalb County government, DeKalb County schools, but now we will have another mouth to feed. If our taxes go down in any meaningful way (and they will not), our services will have to diminish. That much I can promise you. It doesn’t work any other way – ask the good folks in California. I just don’t have a lot of faith in people who are trying to sell me a really good deal at a bargain price. I have seen too many of these promises vanish too quickly.

It’s also my belief that the inclination to divide our communities is not a healthy one. DeKalb County is a diverse community in every sense of the word. The City of Brookhaven will not be. I don’t support that direction. On July 31, I will vote no.

This entry was posted in Policy and Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to The City of Brookhaven: Yes or No?

  1. Bill Aitken '64 says:

    Well, this one really seems like a personal one for you (and those of us commenting can do little more than just that–comment). But based upon many years of experience of dealing with similar issues (as we all have), I can see no advantage to another taxing entity. Your taxes, I believe, would go up and services would diminish. And the other issue, of Oglethorpe being cast as located in an ‘unknown’ location instead of Atlanta, in my mind, confers absolutely no advantage and several potential major disadvantages for image, mission, recruitment, etc. Good luck on this one!

  2. Jeff says:

    Take a look at what is happening now with DeKalb…you are about to have your taxes raised, Teacher and Police are about to be furloughed, you have no representation, the county is broke and run by incompetence. You make the choice!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s